ButlerHomes for Sale in Butler, Tennessee
Johnson County · Watauga Lake · Cherokee National Forest
The Watauga Lake shoreline town — clear water inside a national forest.
Current Butler listings
Active for-sale homes in Butler pulled straight from our listing feeds and refreshed through the day. Counts, prices, and price ranges update as inventory turns over.
Active4 days on market$749,900
571 Hornet Hill Pvt Trail
Butler, TN 37640
MLS# 10002440 · Single Family Residence
Listing courtesy of Boone Real Estate
Active10 days on market$2,225,000
127 Culver Place
Butler, TN 37640
MLS# 10002196 · Single Family Residence
Listing courtesy of Alliance Sotheby's International Realty
Active18 days on market$289,000
129 Dugger Hollow Road
Butler, TN 37640
MLS# 10001688 · Single Family Residence
Listing courtesy of Epique Realty
Active19 days on market$79,000
395 Poga Road
Butler, TN 37640
MLS# 10001823 · Single Family Residence
Listing courtesy of Blackwell Realty & Auction
Active19 days on market$325,000
141 Terrace Private Drive
Butler, TN 37640
MLS# 10001845 · Single Family Residence
Listing courtesy of eXp Realty, LLC
Active22 days on market$539,500
2210 Norris Road
Butler, TN 37640
MLS# 9993364 · Single Family Residence
Listing courtesy of Weichert Realtors Saxon Clark JC
Active25 days on market$675,000
2899 Lakeview Drive
Butler, TN 37640
MLS# 10001616 · Single Family Residence
Listing courtesy of Fathom Realty
Active35 days on market$825,900
120 Andrews Road
Butler, TN 37640
MLS# 10001194 · Single Family Residence
Listing courtesy of REMAX Checkmate, Inc. Realtors
Active41 days on market$219,900
6499 Big Dry Run Road
Butler, TN 37640
MLS# 10000956 · Single Family Residence
Listing courtesy of Waterfront Group PLC, LLC
Active44 days on market$950,000
138 Jd Guinn Lane
Butler, TN 37640
MLS# 10000850 · Single Family Residence
Listing courtesy of Lake Homes Realty Smithville
Active46 days on market$350,000
1120 Myrtle Drive
Butler, TN 37640
MLS# 10000738 · Single Family Residence
Listing courtesy of KW Bristol
Active46 days on market$250,000
0 Roan Creek Road
Butler, TN 37640
MLS# 10000709 · Single Family Residence
Listing courtesy of eXp Realty, LLC
Get new Butler listings the day they come on the market
We watch all of our Tennessee listing feeds and email you when something new comes up in and around Butler — lake frontage, acreage, or in-town homes. No spam, unsubscribe any time.
Listing data courtesy of Tennessee/Virginia Regional MLS
Listing content is provided for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS or Spring Mountain Realty PLLC. All measurements, acreage, room counts, and permitted uses are approximate and should be independently verified by the buyer.
Properties marketed by brokerages other than Spring Mountain Realty PLLC are identified with the listing office name. Listings that a seller has excluded from internet display are not shown, and addresses are withheld where the seller has requested it.
Spring Mountain Realty PLLC is an Equal Housing Opportunity brokerage. We do not provide guidance on schools, demographics, or the composition of any area. Buyers are encouraged to research those subjects using independent public sources.
Live market data
Butler, TN housing market snapshot
These figures are calculated from the Butler homes currently for sale in the local multiple listing services, as of October 26, 2026. They describe asking prices on today's inventory, not closed sale prices.
- Active listings
- 46
- Median days listed
- 103
- Median price / sq ft
- $263
- On an acre or more
- 29
- Mention water frontage
- 14
1 new this week
How long unsold homes have been on the market
Typical home 1,800 sq ft
Acreage listings in Johnson County
Lake, river, or water access noted
Questions about buying and selling in Butler
How many homes are for sale in Butler, TN right now?
There are currently 46 homes for sale in Butler, including 1 listing added in the past week. Spring Mountain Realty pulls this count straight from the local multiple listing services and it refreshes through the day.
How much do houses cost in Butler, TN?
The median asking price across the 46 homes currently listed in Butler is $567,250, with active listings ranging from $79,000 to $7,600,000. That works out to a median of about $263 per square foot. Asking prices are not sale prices — ask us for the recent closed sales on a street you are considering.
Is the Butler housing market moving quickly?
The homes currently for sale in Butler have been listed for a median of 103 days. That measures how long today's unsold inventory has been sitting, so a low number points to a faster market and a high number means buyers have room to negotiate.
Can you buy a house with land in Butler, TN?
Yes — 29 homes of the 46 currently for sale in Butler sit on an acre or more. Acreage in Johnson County is priced very differently from in-town lots, and public records often list the wrong lot size, so we verify acreage and boundaries before you make an offer.
Are there waterfront homes for sale near Butler?
14 listings currently for sale in Butler mention lake, river, or water frontage in the agent's description. Water access varies a great deal — deeded frontage, a community dock, and a seasonal view are all described as "waterfront" — so we confirm exactly what a property conveys before you tour it.
What are homes in Butler, TN typically like?
The typical home for sale in Butler today is about 1,800 square feet and built around 2004, based on the 46 active listings in Johnson County. Housing stock here spans older in-town homes and newer construction, so condition and updates move price more than square footage alone.
How do I find out what my Butler home is worth?
Spring Mountain Realty prepares a written valuation for Butler homeowners using the recent closed sales nearest your property, adjusted for acreage, water access, and condition. Request one at springmountainrealty.com or call 865-935-0500 and a licensed agent will put it together for you.
What homes are selling for in Butler, TN
65 homes have closed in Butler over the past 12 months at a median sale price of $290,000, with sellers getting about 95.2% of their asking price. Below are the most recent closings, shown without addresses.
| Home | Sold for | Asking price | Sq ft | Acres | Closed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 bed, 2 bath | $175,000 | $185,000 | 1,152 | 0.00 | Oct 2026 |
| Home | $99,000 | $135,000 | — | 2.05 | Oct 2026 |
| 2 bed, 1 bath | $170,000 | $185,000 | 672 | 19.00 | Oct 2026 |
| 3 bed, 4 bath | $1,400,000 | $1,550,000 | 2,576 | 1.79 | Oct 2026 |
| Home | $185,000 | $199,900 | — | 14.96 | Oct 2026 |
| Home | $725,000 | $795,000 | — | 107.00 | Oct 2026 |
| 3 bed, 2 bath | $230,000 | $239,900 | 1,910 | 2.82 | Oct 2026 |
| 3 bed, 4 bath | $800,000 | $850,000 | 2,754 | 1.62 | Oct 2026 |
Nearby markets
Compare nearby East Tennessee areas
Free home valuation
What is your Butler home worth today?
Get a value range for your Butler property built from recorded closed sales nearby, then reviewed by a local listing agent. No obligation.
About Butler
Butler is the community on the north side of Watauga Lake, largely rebuilt above the waterline when the reservoir filled in the late 1940s — the original town site is under the lake, which is why it is sometimes called the town that wouldn't drown.
Because the Cherokee National Forest wraps much of the shoreline, private frontage here is scarce and view or deeded-access property is the norm. That scarcity is the defining feature of the local market.
What you'll find on the market
The notes below describe general geography and property types, not any specific listing.
In-town homes
Lake-view cabins and homes above the Watauga shoreline.
Acreage & land
Scarce true-frontage property with permitted dock access.
Views, water & retreats
Wooded mountain acreage bordering national forest.
Newer builds & commercial
Seasonal and rental-oriented cabins near the lake.
Deep mountain water ringed by forest.
Lifestyle
Cold clear water, kayaks and pontoons, Appalachian Trail crossings, and quiet mountain roads with almost no commercial sprawl.
Getting around
- • TN-67 to Mountain City and Elizabethton
- • Elizabethton — about 30 minutes
- • Johnson City — about 45 minutes
- • Boat ramps and marina within minutes
A look around the area
Illustrative scenes of the landscape that shapes the Butler market.
Market context
True lakefront is limited and prices accordingly; most inventory is view homes, cabins, and wooded acreage above the shoreline, plus off-water land. Verify what any deed conveys before assuming frontage.
For current comparable sales, days-on-market, and a property-specific valuation in Butler, request a private CMA from Spring Mountain Realty.
Landmarks & local geography
- Watauga Lake
- Watauga Dam
- Appalachian Trail crossing
- Cherokee National Forest
Outdoor recreation
- Boating and paddling on Watauga
- Trout and smallmouth fishing
- Appalachian Trail hiking
- Cherokee National Forest exploring
Looking in Butler?
Get a private CMA, curated Butler listings, or a valuation for a property here. No spam, no pressure.
Equal Housing Opportunity & Fair Housing Notice
Spring Mountain Realty PLLC complies with the federal Fair Housing Act, the Tennessee Human Rights Act, and the REALTOR® Code of Ethics (including Article 10). We do not discriminate on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, disability, familial status, national origin, sexual orientation, or gender identity.
Information on this page describes Butler's geography, lifestyle, and general real estate market context only. It is not a representation about the makeup of any neighborhood, the character of its residents, school assignments or quality, crime, or the suitability of the area for any particular buyer or household. Buyers are encouraged to conduct their own independent research — including school assignments through Johnson County Schools, property tax data through the county assessor, utility and septic availability, and any other criteria personally important to them — and to consult the relevant public agencies.
Area content is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Property-specific data comes from the MLS and is subject to verification. Nothing on this page constitutes legal, tax, financial, or insurance advice. Images on this page are illustrative and do not depict specific properties for sale.